Photo: rupixen / Unsplash
Black Friday lands on November 27 and Cyber Monday on November 30 this year, but many of the stores that will try to take your money that week are already online, and some won’t be built until the last minute. A wave of new research released in late October and early November describes a holiday shopping season in which fake online stores look more polished than ever, buy real ads on major platforms, show up in search results and even get recommended by AI shopping assistants. At the same time, the Federal Trade Commission is asking the public whether social media, search and shopping platforms should be held more accountable for impersonation ads. Here is what the new findings say, and a practical checklist for getting through the season with your money and your card number intact.
What the new reports found
Savi Security, the Los Angeles company behind the free Scamwise scam-checking tool, published its 2026 Holiday Shopping Scam Report on October 20. It draws on more than a million consumer submissions to Scamwise since March, including more than 250,000 shopping sites. Its headline number: users report a new fake store roughly every three minutes, or about 500 a day. Reports of holiday-themed fake stores grew fivefold over the 60 days before the report came out.
The report paints a picture of stores built to vanish. Seven in ten fake stores were reported only once. Nearly 40 percent were under 90 days old when first flagged, and 85 percent were gone within two weeks. At least one in five traced back to an ad on a major platform, and an “impossible” discount showed up in about one in four. The company is careful to note this is self-reported user data rather than an independent audit, and it is also promoting its own tools, so treat the exact figures as a signal rather than a census. Still, the pattern lines up with what other researchers are seeing. Savi’s chief executive, Patrick Coughlin, put the stakes simply: “Shoppers shouldn’t have to become fraud investigators to buy a gift.”
A separate investigation by NordVPN’s threat intelligence team, reported by Cord Cutters News on November 7, found a network of more than 10,000 counterfeit shopping domains impersonating 166 fashion and luxury brands in 26 countries, with 1,549 stores active as of November 3. These sites didn’t rely on absurd discounts. They used believable prices, local languages and currencies, prestigious-sounding addresses and payment logos that were simply pasted on. Words like “Outlet,” “Sale” and “Black Friday” did the selling. Most traffic came from ordinary search results rather than paid ads, and the researchers found that some AI answer engines and chatbots had cited or even recommended stores from the network as trustworthy.
Meanwhile, the independent testing lab AV-Comparatives ran security products against 500 live fake-shop web addresses in early October and certified seven that caught at least 80 percent of them without flagging any legitimate retailers. That is useful, but it also means even the best tools miss some.
Why this season feels different
For years the standard advice was to look for bad spelling, clumsy design and prices that seemed too good to be true. Those signals are fading. Generative tools make it cheap to produce polished product photos, convincing “about us” pages and full catalogs in minutes. Ready-made e-commerce platforms let anyone open a storefront quickly; Savi says the most common domain among its confirmed scam cases was a popular hosted-store platform, ahead of the big marketplaces combined. And because so many shops disappear within days, blocklists struggle to keep up.
There’s also a new middleman: the AI assistant. More people now ask a chatbot or an AI-powered search feature for “the best deal on” a gift. If a counterfeit site has built up search history, perhaps by taking over an expired domain that once belonged to a real business, those tools can surface it with the same confident tone they use for a legitimate retailer. A recommendation is not a verification.
For small businesses, the problem cuts both ways. Fake stores steal customers and reputation from real brands, and shoppers burned once become more suspicious of every unfamiliar shop, including honest independent sellers.
The FTC wants to hear about imposter ads
On November 2, the FTC posted a consumer alert asking people to weigh in on imposter ads, the paid placements that pretend to be well-known businesses or government agencies. The agency’s existing Impersonation Rule already bans impersonating businesses and government. Now it is considering updating that rule, or writing a new one, to make social media companies, search engines and other digital marketplaces more accountable. Ideas it floated include vetting advertisers before ads run, giving people an easy way to report impersonation ads, and investigating and removing ads that turn out to be scams. The FTC said comments are due November 30, 2026, through the Federal Register notice linked from its alert. If you have been fooled by a look-alike ad, your experience is exactly what the agency says it wants to hear.
A holiday checkout checklist
None of these steps is foolproof on its own. Together they make you a much harder target.
- Start from a place you trust. Type the retailer’s address yourself or use its official app instead of tapping an ad, a social post, a text or a chatbot link.
- Read the web address slowly. Look for extra letters, inserted hyphens, odd country endings, or a brand name bolted onto a generic domain.
- Research the store, not just the product. Search the store’s name with words like “reviews” or “scam.” Ask whether anyone outside its own website has heard of it. A brand-new shop with a glossy catalog and no outside footprint deserves caution.
- Be extra careful with social media ads. Several of these reports point to ads on big platforms as a key on-ramp. An ad that runs in your feed has not been vouched for by anyone.
- Don’t trust payment logos. Anyone can paste a card network’s logo onto a page. What matters is how you actually pay.
- Use a payment method with buyer protection. Credit cards generally give you stronger dispute rights than debit cards, wire transfers, gift cards, crypto or payment apps sent to strangers. Some cards and phone wallets also offer virtual card numbers that limit what a thief can reuse.
- Slow down when the clock is ticking. Countdown timers and “only 2 left” banners are designed to rush you past your own judgment.
- Keep records. Screenshot the product page, order confirmation and any chat with “customer service.” You’ll want them if you have to dispute a charge.
- Stay alert after checkout. Fake delivery texts, phony order confirmations and refund scams tend to spike after big shopping days. Check order status in the retailer’s own app or site, never through a link in an unexpected message.
If you think you bought from a fake store
- Call your card issuer or bank right away using the number on the back of your card. Ask them to block the card and dispute the charge.
- Change any password you created on the site, and anywhere else you reused it.
- Watch your statements for small “test” charges, which often come before bigger ones.
- Report it to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If the store reached you through an ad, report the ad on the platform where you saw it, too.
- Be suspicious of anyone who contacts you offering to “recover” your money for a fee. That is often a second scam.
This is general consumer information, not legal or financial advice. If significant money is involved, talk with your bank and, if needed, a qualified professional.
What to watch next
Expect the volume of fake stores to keep climbing right up to Cyber Monday and then shift into fake shipping notices and return scams in December. Watch whether the big ad platforms announce tighter advertiser checks before the FTC’s November 30 comment deadline, and whether AI shopping assistants start telling users how they verified a store, not just which store to pick. Retailers and security companies are racing to build checkers into browsers and phones; those tools help, but the lab results show they still miss some sites.
The bottom line
The holidays are a season of generosity, and scammers count on that. The good news is that a few unglamorous habits, such as typing addresses yourself, paying with protected methods, and pausing before you tap “buy,” still defeat most of these schemes, however slick the storefront looks. Share this checklist with the people you shop for. Protecting someone’s wallet is a pretty good gift, too.
Sources: Savi Security 2026 Holiday Shopping Scam Report release (via Yahoo Finance); Cord Cutters News on NordVPN’s fake-store research; AV-Comparatives fake-shop test (via Taiwan News); Federal Trade Commission consumer alert.
Quick check
How much did you catch? Tap a question to see the answer.
1. According to Savi Security’s report, roughly how often do users report a new fake store?
Answer: About every three minutes, or roughly 500 a day, based on submissions to its Scamwise tool.
2. What is the FTC asking the public about this month?
Answer: Whether social media, search and shopping platforms should do more about imposter ads, such as vetting advertisers and removing scam ads. Comments are due November 30, 2026.
3. Why is a credit card usually a safer way to pay online than a debit card or gift card?
Answer: Credit cards generally offer stronger dispute rights, so it is easier to challenge a charge from a fake store.