Photo: Dan Nelson / Unsplash
A New Mexico judge has ordered Meta to pay the state $25 billion after a jury found the company liable for deceiving users about their privacy on Facebook, the largest penalty ever imposed on the social media giant. The ruling, issued in late October, grows out of the Cambridge Analytica scandal from the 2016 election era, and Meta has said it will appeal. Whatever happens in the higher courts, the case is a useful prompt for every Facebook and Instagram user to ask a basic question: what have I actually agreed to share, and with whom?
What the court decided
In September, a New Mexico jury found Meta liable for more than 43 million violations of the state’s consumer protection laws. The case centered on how a third-party personality quiz app harvested data from roughly 87 million Facebook profiles and passed it to Cambridge Analytica, a now-defunct political consulting firm whose clients included Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign. Jurors weighed 34 allegedly misleading statements Meta made about privacy and content moderation.
Judge Francis J. Matthew then set the penalty. In his ruling he wrote that Facebook had told users they controlled their own data, and that this was not true. New Mexico had asked for $35 billion to $40 billion, arguing that only a sum large enough to affect Meta’s stock price would change its behavior. Meta argued for no more than $3.4 billion and said anything far larger would violate due process. The final $25 billion dwarfs the $5 billion fine the Federal Trade Commission imposed on Facebook in 2019.
Attorney General Raúl Torrez called the judgment “an unambiguous message, to Silicon Valley.” Under New Mexico’s constitution, the money would go to education, though it will be tied up during the appeal, and interest will accrue in the meantime.
Meta’s side
Meta argued the state never proved its privacy statements were misleading or that any New Mexican saw them or was harmed by them. Its lawyers called the method of counting violations, based on how many people may have seen the statements, unprecedented, and said the state’s evidence was outdated. The company says it has changed its policies since the lawsuit was filed in 2021. Jurors did side with Meta on one point: they did not find that Facebook made false claims about removing harmful content, including COVID-19 misinformation. Meta has said it will appeal, and the number of violations could be reduced.
The case also stands apart because New Mexico, along with Florida, declined to join a separate multistate settlement Meta reached in August over teen social media addiction. That settlement included a release from future liability tied to Cambridge Analytica, which New Mexico did not sign.
Why this matters to everyday users
Cambridge Analytica is old news in internet years, but the mechanism behind it is not. A fun quiz, a game, or a “log in with Facebook” button can give a third-party developer access to information about you, and sometimes, under older rules, about your friends. Platforms have tightened those permissions since 2018, but apps and websites you connected years ago may still be linked to your account. Most people have never looked.
The verdict also highlights a gap many users feel: privacy promises are written by the companies making them. The New Mexico jury concluded that some of those promises were misleading. That doesn’t mean every setting is meaningless, but it does mean your own choices, and what you decide not to share, carry real weight.
There’s a household angle, too. Data about you can leak through other people’s choices. When a friend or relative grants an app access to their account, contact lists and photos that include you may come along. Talking about privacy as a family, not just as individuals, closes some of those side doors.
Questions to ask before you connect any app
The best privacy setting is the permission you never grant. Before you tap “continue with Facebook,” or any other social login, ask yourself:
- What is this app actually asking for? Read the permission screen. A personality quiz has no good reason to need your friends list, photos or contacts.
- Who made it? If you can’t tell which company is behind an app or game, that’s a reason to skip it.
- Do I need an account at all? Many sites work fine as a guest. If you do sign up, an email login you control can be easier to disconnect later than a social login.
- Will I remember this connection in a year? If not, set a reminder to review connected apps a few times a year. Linked services pile up quietly.
A 15-minute privacy checkup for Facebook and Instagram
Meta moves menus around often, so the exact names may differ on your phone, but these steps are worth doing on any social app.
- Review connected apps and websites. In Facebook’s settings, look for the section listing apps and websites you’ve logged into with Facebook. Remove anything you don’t recognize or no longer use, especially old quiz and game apps.
- Check your off-platform activity. Meta lets you see and disconnect information that businesses share with it about your activity on their sites and apps. Clear it and turn off future linking if you prefer.
- Run the built-in Privacy Checkup. It walks you through who can see your posts, your profile details and how people can find you.
- Visit Accounts Center. This is where Meta groups settings shared across Facebook, Instagram and Messenger, including ad preferences and connected experiences.
- Limit old posts. There is usually an option to restrict the audience of past posts to friends in one step.
- Turn on two-factor authentication and review active sessions. Log out of devices you don’t recognize.
- Download your information. Seeing the file Meta has about you is often the most persuasive privacy lesson of all.
For small businesses that use Meta tools
If your business runs Facebook or Instagram ads, uses a tracking pixel on your website, or lets customers log in with a social account, the trust questions in this case apply to you, too. Make sure your own privacy policy accurately describes what you collect and share. Audit who has admin access to your business pages and ad accounts. And don’t collect customer data you don’t actually need. Being able to say “we never had it” is the best defense against a data problem. This is general information, not legal advice; for specific compliance questions, talk with a qualified attorney.
What to watch next
- The appeal. Meta’s challenge could take a long time and could shrink the penalty or the violation count.
- An injunction. New Mexico is also seeking a court order to stop similar practices, which could matter more to users than the dollar figure.
- Copycat cases. A massive verdict built on per-violation counting under state consumer law may encourage other states to bring their own privacy cases against tech companies.
- Federal privacy law. The U.S. still has no comprehensive national privacy law, leaving states and courts to fill the gap.
The takeaway
A $25 billion judgment makes headlines, but your privacy is decided in much smaller moments: the quiz you skip, the app you disconnect, the setting you finally check. Spend 15 minutes this week on that checkup, then help a parent or grandparent do the same while you’re together for the holidays.
Source: The Associated Press, republished by PBS NewsHour.
Quick check
How much did you catch? Tap a question to see the answer.
1. How many violations of New Mexico consumer protection law did the jury find?
Answer: More than 43 million.
2. How did Cambridge Analytica get Facebook data at the center of this case?
Answer: A third-party personality quiz app harvested data from roughly 87 million profiles and passed it to the firm.
3. Where will the money go if the judgment survives appeal?
Answer: Under New Mexico’s constitution, consumer protection fines go to state education spending.